Bailey Edward Joins CPLBringing our teams together to better serve our clients and communities.

Read the Announcement
  • Observations

Building a Brighter Future: “Empowerment, not Power”

Have you ever wondered what more than 1,000 designers, planners, entrepreneurs, and students have in common? Lauren Garriott, Bailey Edward Designer and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Working Group Leader, attended the National Organization of Minority ARchitect’s annual conference in October 2021 and brought back new strategies in which we can use design to transform the built environment for the social good. This mini series will take a deep dive into three key concepts from the conference: Empowerment Not Power; If It Hasn’t Been Done Before, Do It Yourself; and Mentorship for Life.

In honor of February being recognized as Black History Month, we will kick off this mini series about building a brighter future through a diversity, equity and inclusion lens with the first key takeaway. In October of 2021, the National Organization of Minority Architects (NOMA) held their annual conference celebrating their 50th anniversary since the organization’s founding by twelve Black architects at the 1971 AIA Conference in Detroit. With over 1,000 attendees participating in-person and virtually, everyone was excited to honor NOMA’s history and accomplishments and engage in meaningful conversations about building a “brighter future for our profession and our communities.”

101 sessions were offered revolving around the topics of design, technology, community and justice, business development, the legacy of NOMA, and history of Detroit. Over twenty schools competed for monetary awards for their NOMA Student Chapters through the annual NOMA student design competition.

The three days that spanned the conference were full of enthusiasm and willingness to listen, learn and actively engage in conversations about how we, as designers, planners, entrepreneurs, and students, can make a positive impact in our society while promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). While there were several lessons learned from my own participation in the conference, I will begin by breaking down the first of three key concepts:

#1: Empowerment, Not Power

In 2019, Minneapolis permitted the expansion of CPTED (Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design) practices for all new and existing developments. CPTED was developed to establish design principles reducing crime and control “unwanted” social behavior patterns. Cities may choose to enact these with amendments to fit their needs. While it is important for people to feel safe in public spaces, the design principles and policies intended to improve a sense of safety can increase anxiety and fear for people of color, like making a space seem exclusionary with improper placement of fencing and signage. In practice some CPTED strategies can be abused and end up supporting the same suppressive aim as “stop-and-frisk” policing, ensuring anyone considered suspicious feels uncomfortable—a feeling that minorities tend to experience daily. For instance, orientation of building entries and windows to the street may provide natural surveillance but can shape a mentality that specific people need to be controlled, targeted or apprehended, because CPTED puts a major focus on identifying between “legitimate” and “illegitimate” users of space. Distinguishing people in this way is inherently a value-based process that is constantly sabotaged. Although the intent is to protect against universal dangers, not all people may feel safe.

“Empowerment, not power” was a powerful phrase I heard from a session titled ” presented by Triveece Penelton, Jeff Williams, Phil Dougherty and Emmet Pierson, Jr. This session sparked discussion about our role in eliminating barriers that limit access and reinforce disparity. We must learn to recognize some physical and invisible barriers, from strategic division of private and public spaces to modern-day redlining caused by biased banking practices.  Natural surveillance and the illusion of security is often prioritized over sustainability and mental health as well. It is this sense of an invisible barrier that can be equally limiting as a physical one. A few instances are known with predominantly Black neighborhoods across Los Angeles where several trees were removed because police believed suspects could stash illicit items in the foliage. The removal of these trees has negatively impacted community health and well-being by taking away a source of comfort, community identity, social interaction and a way to remove air pollution. Another CPTED concept encourages locating parking behind public housing to foster safety. However, this practice will often lessen people’s social interactions and face time with the front street and community at large, enabling an environment of distrust. Eliminating these barriers is one important step of many in transforming a population embedded in systemic racism and bias into a truly equitable and inclusive society, which makes for a more resilient and thriving economy. Therefore, it is vital for architects, engineers, and interior designers to respond to the actual needs of all communities and empower all community members.

As designers we should be advocates for all communities because creating an environment prioritizing social impact, subsequent health, and sense of place will encourage community growth and development of social relationships and trust. Rebuilding a society with more inclusionary, diverse and equitable communities will support for reduction and fear of crime. How do we motivate our communities to commit to this vision? Start by holding an outdoor community event in a vacant open space and imagine how that space can be used by encouraging the community to engage with each other and the space, like the public housing residents of communities in Staten Island and Brooklyn did through the “Mayor’s Action Plan for Neighborhood Safety” (MAP) initiative. You can learn more strategies to activate and create safe places through New York City’s playbook culminated by the MAP initiative.

Movable seating, tents, and a kiosk transformed the court into a place to support new social interactions in Staten Island.

Image Credit: Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice and the Center for Court Innovation.

A night dance party at Brownsville Houses in Brooklyn created a new positive experience in a place seen as unsafe by the community.

Image Credit: Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice and the Center for Court Innovation.

This key message of empowerment was also seen from a sustainability-focused perspective in a session titled “The Crisis of Climate Change & Energy Burden” presented by Sheryl Owens and Satpal Kaur. It brought to focus that while most projects strive to have a positive environmental impact, many allow sustainability to become a “commodity only to those who can afford it.” As such, we should encourage active community participation throughout the design process, so we develop solutions that are the most impactful rather than the most convenient to the client. For instance, a Detroit community redesigned their street medians to better integrate with stormwater management while enhancing community identity. In personally investing efforts to make a healthier, sustainable, and beautiful neighborhood, community members have gained a sense of pride and meaningful connection with their space– this can show that just one small change where the idea of “empowerment, not power” is impactful. Here, at Bailey Edward, we always make sustainability an imperative goal by designing to LEED Silver at a minimum even if the client is not actively pursuing sustainability objectives because we value in designing for the social good and constantly strive to learn and do better.

Image Credit: Detroit Water & Sewage Dept. as shown by Sheryl Owens and Satpal Kaur. “The Crisis of Climate Change & Energy Burden.”

As designers we have the responsibility to protect the health, safety and welfare for all people through the spaces we design. Empowerment should mean power for someone to do something, not power given to someone. It means protecting not withholding. Preserving not oppressing. Inspiring not imposing. And supporting not suppressing. As you reflect on what Black History Month means to you and how far we have come in elevating Black voices, I encourage you to begin looking through this DEI lens by bringing social impact as a focus into the conversation with stakeholders by centering choice and voice throughout the process.

 

About the Author

Lauren Garriott is a designer working out of Bailey Edward’s Champaign Office. Her passions lie in the intersections of health, well-being and design. She strives to incorporate these values into affordable housing, public housing, and humanitarian architecture. Lauren is a member of NOMA and received her Master of Architecture from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaig